I know very well that Christmas is over but I really can’t wait till this year’s Christmas to review this movie. So…
Some of you might be aware of the World War Christmas truce of 1914 when many widespread unofficial ceasefires took place along the Western Front. It is not a myth, and truly something amazing that took place – there are many survivors who could attest to that, and many letters sent home to show proof that it indeed took place. Of course, back then the soldiers involved in this weird and unprecedented move were not seen as heroes, but more as errant soliders who defied their superiors’ orders. Most of them were deemed to have commited high treason and were duly punished with forfeited visits to their families or sent to harsher frontiers etc.
I learnt about this historical event some months back when I was researching for this past trip and what we could do on Christmas Eve. What I didn’t expect was that it had been made into a film! It was indeed fortunate that I could catch this movie on our flight home from Paris.
I never liked movies showing scenes of war. I couldn’t sleep well for days after watching ‘Saving Private Ryan’. ’Blackhawk Down’ was only a little worse. As a general rule, I don’t watch movies of such genre because they disturb me profoundly. But ‘Joyeux Noel’, which is a French movie by the way, is not just about World War I. It’s about humanity, and how even our enemy is as human as we are, with family and loved ones. We tend to forget this little truth when we get so caught up in our own passionate disdain.
Somehow this movie reminds me a little of what Atticus Finch told his children in ‘To Kill a Mockingbird’ – that we never really know a man until we stand in his shoes and walk around in them. In the book, that sentence stemmed from Atticus’ attempt at trying to teach Jem and Scout about prejudice. This movie is no different, really. It was made easier to kill the ‘enemies’ because propaganda had pictured the enemies as barbaric and inhumane. This was especially highlighted when Father Palmer rebutted the bishop about the true meaning of Christmas, and how the bishop swiftly went on to preach an anti-German sermon to the new troop taking over Father Palmer’s disgraced troop.
I could think of one reason why the superiors were upset with the troops that practiced the Christmas truce, because fact is, it makes it a lot harder to kill the other person along the enemies’ lines when you know who they are, how they missed their loved ones, and how they, like you, had no choice but to be conscripted to go to war. These young men realised it didn’t matter what nationality they were, or what language they spoke, because they were in actual fact no different. This is the one true sign of humanity.
I like this movie. In fact I like it so much that I have bought it over iTunes and am now downloading it to re-watch it.
10/250

















Recent Comments